The Difference Between Amorphous Cores and Nanocrystalline Cores

Oct 16, 2025

Leave a message

Introduction

Amorphous and nanocrystalline cores are both advanced soft magnetic materials used in high-performance transformers, chokes and current transformers. Both are produced by rapid solidification of a molten alloy into a thin ribbon, but they differ in atomic structure, magnetic properties and cost, which determines where each material is the best choice.

This article compares the two materials across structure, permeability, coercivity, saturation flux density, core loss and typical applications.

Atomic Structure

Amorphous alloy has a non-crystalline, disordered atomic arrangement. The ribbon is formed by quenching the melt so quickly, at cooling rates around 10^6 K/s, that the atoms cannot arrange into crystals. Nanocrystalline alloy starts from the same amorphous ribbon but is then annealed under controlled conditions so that fine grains of about 10-30 nm precipitate in the amorphous matrix, creating a two-phase structure with extremely low magnetostriction.

Magnetic Properties Compared

Property Amorphous Nanocrystalline
Typical initial permeability 1,000-10,000 (as-cast, higher after field annealing) 80,000-120,000
Coercivity Lower than silicon steel Lower than amorphous, often below 1 A/m
Saturation flux density 1.5-1.6 T (Fe-based) 1.2-1.25 T
Core loss at 20 kHz, 0.2 T About 10-20 W/kg About 3-10 W/kg
Curie temperature About 415 C (Fe-based) About 570 C
Relative cost Moderate Higher

Applications

Amorphous cores are chosen where a combination of high saturation and low loss is needed at moderate cost: distribution transformer cores, high-frequency transformers, saturable reactors and some current transformers. Iron-based amorphous cores are the standard choice for amorphous distribution transformers because of their very low no-load loss.

Nanocrystalline cores are preferred for precision and high-frequency applications: high-accuracy current transformers, common-mode chokes in EMC filters, magnetic amplifiers, and inductors for inverters, UPS systems and EV chargers. Their very high permeability allows a smaller core for the same impedance, and their low magnetostriction keeps noise low.

Selection Guide

Choose amorphous when high saturation flux density and low material cost matter, for example in distribution transformer cores.

Choose nanocrystalline when very high permeability, low phase error or high impedance at high frequency is required.

For temperatures above 150 C, check the Curie temperature and the thermal ageing behaviour of the selected grade.

For current transformers, define the accuracy class (for example 0.2 or 0.5) and the burden per IEC 61869-2 before selecting the core material.

FAQ

Q: Which material has the higher permeability?
A: Nanocrystalline, with an initial permeability typically of 80,000-120,000, well above amorphous grades.

Q: Which material has the higher saturation flux density?
A: Iron-based amorphous alloy, about 1.5-1.6 T, compared with 1.2-1.25 T for nanocrystalline.

Q: Are the two materials interchangeable?
A: No. The optimum choice depends on the operating frequency, accuracy requirement and cost target.

Q: Why is nanocrystalline used in current transformers?
A: Its very high permeability gives a low magnetizing current and therefore low ratio and phase errors, even with few primary turns.

Q: How are these ribbons produced?
A: By planar-flow casting, where molten alloy is ejected onto a rotating copper wheel and solidifies into ribbon tens of micrometres thick.

Q: Can both materials be supplied as cut cores?
A: Yes, both are available in cut (gapped) form for installation around existing conductors.

Send Inquiry