Is thinner better? The electrical steel in the motor is just the right thickness

Nov 27, 2023

Leave a message

GNEE New Materialal Steel

When choosing the right electrical steel for your motor, several factors must be considered.
Of course, the magnetic and mechanical properties of the material are more decisive. The thinner the material, the lower the eddy current losses at high frequencies. The efficiency of the motor increases. This in turn means lower power consumption, allowing for a higher range at the same battery capacity level.

silicon steel sheet

However, what impact does the thickness of electrical steel have on factors such as stampability, available stamping capacity, required stamping technology, availability in the market and ultimately on the price of the material? Besides efficiency, are there any other technical factors in the design of the motor that require different thicknesses? Should the electric motor only act as a support for the internal combustion engine (mild hybrid), or should it independently drive the car up to a certain speed and cover shorter distances using electricity only (plug-in hybrid)? Or should the electric motor alone take the car a long distance (electric car)?
Is lower thickness really always a better choice from an overall perspective? The sheets are thinner, production times are longer and throughput is reduced.

Let us take as an example a motor with a stator outer diameter of 250 mm and a stack height of 120 mm. The thinner the board thickness, the more laminations required to achieve the desired overall height. The stamping speed varies between 220 strokes/min (0.25mm thick sheet) and 250 strokes/min (0.35mm thick), depending on the sheet thickness. Taking into account scrap, downtime and system availability, the output will be between 32 layers (0.35 mm) and 19 layers (0.25 mm) per hour, which means a 1.7-fold increase in stamping time.

electrical steel sheet

Impact on global stamping capabilities

According to (very conservative) estimates, 25 million drive motors will be needed by 2025, which means that at least 60 high-precision stamping lines/presses will be installed for individual switches with thicknesses from 0.35 mm to 0.25 mm.

cold rolled electrical steel

A wide range of electrical steel grades are available to produce strong and powerful electric motors. When choosing a drive motor for purely electric operation, the first question is how much overall cost savings can be achieved by using higher quality, thinner, and therefore more expensive electrical steel. Even relatively small differences in efficiency can affect range and thus the required (very expensive) battery capacity.

Performance profile requirements if the electric motor is used solely to support the internal combustion engine (as in a mild hybrid vehicle), or if the vehicle is intended to operate purely on electric power over short or short to medium distances, as in a hybrid or plug-in hybrid vehicle lower. In addition to saving material in the engine, the required battery capacity is also significantly reduced. This is why it makes sense to reduce motor efficiency by using thicknesses in the range of 0.3 and 0.35 mm.
Laminates are either welded or loosely stacked together. How these are combined depends on your preferred or required application. Whether the laminations are loose, bonded or welded, these materials are preferred over solid materials in order to reduce eddy current losses. In addition, very thin electrical steel can improve the efficiency of high-speed motors, especially in stators, but in rotors, very high strength is often required rather than thinner thickness. Special connection processes, such as full-surface bonding, enable the rotor design to also have a positive impact on efficiency.

In conclusion

Thinner is not always better. The use of electrical steel must be viewed in a very differentiated way from the overall perspective of processability, cost, application areas, efficiency and other technical factors of motor design. Many conditions clearly support the use of various thicknesses of electrical steel.

Send Inquiry