1600 kVA ONAN/ONAF vs 800 kVA Oil-Filled Transformer: Cooling and Efficiency
Jan 28, 2026
Leave a message
Cooling Modes Explained
Liquid-immersed transformers are classified by their cooling mode under IEC 60076-2. ONAN means oil natural, air natural: the oil circulates by convection and the heat is removed by natural air flow over the tank. ONAF means oil natural, air forced: fans blow air over the coolers, increasing heat removal and therefore the continuous rating. For a transformer with a dual ONAN/ONAF rating, the ONAF rating is typically about 30-40% higher than the ONAN rating.
800 kVA Oil-Filled Transformer Profile
An 800 kVA oil-filled transformer is a single-rating distribution unit, usually ONAN. Its advantages are simplicity, low maintenance, and a proven design. It suits a site whose maximum demand is stable and below 800 kVA, with limited expectations of growth. The absence of fans and control gear reduces first cost and removes a maintenance item.
1600 kVA ONAN/ONAF Transformer Profile
A 1600 kVA unit with dual cooling can operate continuously at its ONAN rating, for example about 1200 kVA, and step up to 1600 kVA when the fans run. The forced-air stage is designed for short peaks and for seasonal or shift-based load increases, so the tank does not have to be oversized for the whole year. This flexibility is the main reason a plant chooses a dual-rated unit over a single-rating transformer of the same peak capacity.
Efficiency and Loss Comparison
No-load loss depends mainly on the core and is present for all 8760 hours of the year. Load loss grows with the square of the load current. For two candidates serving the same site, the annual energy loss can be estimated as:
E_loss = P0 x 8760 + Pk x (S_avg / Sr)^2 x T_loaded
where P0 is the no-load loss, Pk is the load loss at rated current, S_avg is the average load, Sr is the rated capacity, and T_loaded is the loaded hours. The 1600 kVA unit has a larger core and a higher P0, so its advantage appears only when the load actually uses the extra capacity; at light load, the 800 kVA unit may be more economical.
When to Choose Which
| Factor | 800 kVA single rating | 1600 kVA ONAN/ONAF |
|---|---|---|
| Load pattern | stable, below 800 kVA | variable with peaks above 1200 kVA |
| Future growth | limited margin | headroom for expansion |
| First cost | lower | higher, plus fan control gear |
| Efficiency at light load | better | higher no-load loss penalty |
| Maintenance | simple | fans and controls to maintain |
Selection Checklist
Record the annual load curve, including seasonal and shift peaks.
Calculate the capitalized loss cost for both candidates.
Check the space and ventilation for fans and coolers.
Confirm the utility fault level against the transformer impedance.
Verify that the tap range and connection group match the network.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does an ONAN/ONAF dual rating mean in practice?
The transformer can run continuously at its ONAN rating without fans; when the load rises, the fans start and the rating steps up to the ONAF value, giving operating flexibility.
How much higher is the ONAF rating than the ONAN rating?
Typically about 30-40% higher; for example, a unit rated 1200 kVA ONAN can be rated 1600 kVA ONAF.
Is an 800 kVA transformer more efficient than a 1600 kVA one?
At the same load level, the 800 kVA unit usually has lower total losses because its load loss is lower at partial load; the 1600 kVA unit only pays off when the load exceeds the smaller unit capacity.
Can fans be added to an existing 800 kVA transformer?
Only if the tank, windings, and bushing ratings were designed for the higher temperature rise; retrofitting fans without design verification is not recommended.
How is the dual rating tested?
Temperature-rise tests are performed for both cooling modes per IEC 60076-2, and the loss values are measured at rated current.
Which option suits a site with expected load growth?
A 1600 kVA ONAN/ONAF unit with an initial ONAN rating above the current demand provides headroom and avoids a second transformer purchase within a few years.

